When Is Probate Required? (And When It's Not)

Probate Questions 10 min read

Settling an estate in NC? Afterpath guides you through probate step by step — $199 vs $10,000+ attorney fees.

Introduction

When a loved one passes away, one of the first questions families face is: “Do we need probate?” The answer isn’t always straightforward, as it depends on several factors including the size of the estate, how assets are titled, and your state’s specific laws.

Probate is the legal process that validates a will, inventories assets, pays debts and taxes, and distributes remaining property according to either the will or state law. While probate serves important functions, it can be time-consuming and expensive, sometimes costing thousands of dollars in legal fees and court costs.

Understanding when probate is required and when it can be avoided is essential for efficient estate planning. This guide explores the scenarios that trigger probate requirements and the strategies that allow assets to transfer outside the probate system.

When Probate IS Required

Assets Titled in the Deceased’s Individual Name

Probate becomes necessary when the deceased person holds significant assets in their individual name with no designated beneficiary. Common examples include:

Real estate (house, rental properties, land)
Bank accounts without payable-on-death (POD) designations
Investment accounts held individually
Vehicles and personal property of substantial value
Business interests without succession planning

If these assets lack a clear mechanism for transfer outside probate, the court must oversee their distribution to ensure creditors are paid and heirs receive their rightful inheritance.

Estate Value Exceeds State Minimums

Most states establish thresholds below which probate can be avoided through simplified procedures. The requirement to go through formal probate typically applies when the estate’s total value exceeds these limits.

For example, North Carolina sets these thresholds:

$20,000 for general estates without real property
$30,000 for estates where the surviving spouse is the only heir

If your estate falls below these amounts, you may qualify for a streamlined “small estate” process instead of full probate.

No Will, Trust, or Beneficiary Designations

When someone dies without any estate planning documents, their assets must pass through probate according to state intestacy laws. Without a will, trust, or beneficiary designations, the court appoints an administrator to manage the estate and distribute assets to heirs according to a statutory priority list.

This situation creates delays and reduces family autonomy in deciding how to distribute the estate. It also increases the likelihood of disputes among heirs.

Disputes Over the Estate

If heirs challenge a will’s validity or dispute how assets should be distributed, the probate court provides the necessary forum to resolve these conflicts. Probate becomes mandatory when legal disputes require judicial oversight.

When Probate IS NOT Required

Joint Tenancy with Right of Survivorship

Assets held as “joint tenants with right of survivorship” automatically transfer to the surviving co-owner outside probate. When one joint tenant dies, their interest passes directly to the other joint tenant(s) by operation of law.

Common examples include:

Joint bank accounts
Jointly owned real estate
Brokerage accounts registered as joint tenants

The key advantage is the automatic transfer without court involvement. However, joint ownership has potential drawbacks, including unintended tax consequences and exposure to the co-owner’s creditors.

Tenancy by the Entirety

In states that recognize tenancy by the entirety, married couples can hold property with automatic survivorship rights similar to joint tenancy. Upon one spouse’s death, the property passes entirely to the surviving spouse without probate.

Tenancy by the entirety offers added creditor protection compared to joint tenancy, as neither spouse can unilaterally sever the arrangement.

Payable-on-Death (POD) and Transfer-on-Death (TOD) Accounts

Many financial institutions allow account holders to designate beneficiaries who automatically receive funds upon the account owner’s death. These designations include:

Payable-on-death bank accounts: Funds transfer directly to named beneficiaries
Beneficiary-designated investment accounts: Stocks, bonds, and mutual funds transfer to beneficiaries
Transfer-on-death vehicle registrations: In some states, vehicles automatically transfer to designated beneficiaries

These accounts are part of your probate estate on paper, but the beneficiary designation supersedes any will instruction, allowing direct transfer outside probate.

Beneficiary Designations on Retirement Accounts and Life Insurance

Retirement accounts (IRAs, 401(k)s) and life insurance policies are specifically designed to pass outside probate through beneficiary designations. The policy or account contract controls the distribution, not your will.

Important: Beneficiary designations override your will. If you name an ex-spouse as beneficiary on a life insurance policy and later remarry, that ex-spouse still receives the proceeds unless you update the beneficiary designation.

Living Trusts

A revocable living trust is one of the most effective probate avoidance tools. By transferring assets into the trust during life, those assets bypass probate entirely. The trustee manages and distributes trust assets according to your instructions without court involvement.

Living trusts offer additional benefits:

Privacy: Trust distributions aren’t public record like probate proceedings
Incapacity planning: The successor trustee can manage assets if you become incapacitated
Continuity: Assets transfer immediately without court delays

However, setting up and maintaining a living trust requires upfront time and cost.

Community Property with Right of Survivorship

In community property states (Arizona, California, Idaho, Nevada, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin), married couples can hold property as “community property with right of survivorship.” This designation combines the benefits of community property treatment with automatic survivorship, allowing the property to pass to the surviving spouse outside probate.

Small Estate Procedures

Nearly every state offers simplified procedures for small estates that don’t meet the probate threshold. These procedures typically include:

Affidavit procedures: Heirs submit sworn statements rather than going to court
Small estate summary administration: Streamlined court process with minimal court involvement
Simplified administration: Expedited proceedings for very small estates

North Carolina small estate thresholds:

$20,000 for estates without real property
$30,000 for estates where the surviving spouse is the only heir

If your estate qualifies, you avoid the time and expense of formal probate.

Assets with No Probate Value

Certain assets have no probate value because they’ve already been effectively transferred:

Vehicles held in joint names
Property with paid-up mortgages that transfer automatically
Gifts made before death (the deceased no longer owned them)
Assets that depreciated to zero value

Special Considerations for North Carolina

North Carolina Small Estate Exemptions

North Carolina provides generous small estate procedures under N.C. General Statute § 28A-28-1. If the estate’s total value doesn’t exceed these thresholds, probate can be avoided:

$20,000 gross value for estates without real property
$30,000 gross value for estates where the surviving spouse is the sole heir

To qualify, the estate’s total assets minus valid debts and taxes must fall within these limits. The surviving spouse can use a simple affidavit procedure to claim property.

North Carolina’s Uniform Transfer on Death (TOD) Act

North Carolina allows transfer-on-death registrations for real property under N.C. General Statute § 39-6.2 et seq. Property holders can register real estate with a TOD designation, allowing it to transfer automatically to the named beneficiary without probate.

North Carolina Homestead Allowance

North Carolina provides a homestead allowance of $60,000 (adjusted annually) that passes to the surviving spouse or, if none, to the decedent’s heirs outside probate. This exemption protects a portion of the family home from creditors’ claims.

How to Determine if Probate Is Needed

Ask yourself these key questions:

Is the estate large? If total assets exceed your state’s small estate threshold, probate may be required.
Are assets titled individually? Assets held in the decedent’s individual name without beneficiary designations typically require probate.
Are there designated beneficiaries? POD accounts, TOD registrations, life insurance, and retirement accounts with named beneficiaries bypass probate.
Is there a trust? Assets in a revocable living trust transfer outside probate.
Were assets jointly owned? Joint tenancy or tenancy by the entirety avoid probate.
Are there disputes or debts? If creditors need to be notified or heirs dispute the distribution, probate provides a formal mechanism to resolve these issues.

If most assets have beneficiary designations or are held in trust, you likely don’t need probate. If a significant portion is titled individually without a beneficiary, probate is probably necessary.

FAQ Section: When Is Probate Required?

Q1: Does an estate need to go through probate even if there’s a will?

Answer: Not necessarily. A will doesn’t automatically trigger probate. If all assets have beneficiary designations, are held in joint names, or are in a trust, probate can be avoided even with a will. Probate is required only if you have assets titled individually without designated beneficiaries that exceed your state’s small estate threshold. The will itself doesn’t determine whether probate is needed, the asset titles and designations do.

Q2: Can joint bank accounts avoid probate?

Answer: Yes. Joint bank accounts with right of survivorship automatically transfer to the surviving co-owner outside probate. However, joint accounts have drawbacks: all joint owners can access all funds during life, and joint ownership may create unintended gift tax consequences. Additionally, the account becomes accessible to the co-owner’s creditors. Set up joint accounts carefully or consider POD accounts as an alternative.

Q3: What happens if someone dies without a will in North Carolina?

Answer: North Carolina intestacy laws determine distribution. Property passes to the surviving spouse (if any), then to children, then parents, then siblings, and so forth according to a statutory priority. If the estate doesn’t exceed $20,000 (or $30,000 with a surviving spouse as sole heir), simplified small estate procedures apply. Otherwise, a court-appointed administrator manages probate. A will or trust prevents the state from deciding how your estate is distributed.

Q4: Do retirement accounts and life insurance need probate?

Answer: No. Retirement accounts (IRAs, 401(k)s) and life insurance policies pass directly to named beneficiaries outside probate. The beneficiary designation controls distribution, not your will. However, if no beneficiary is named, these assets may enter the probate estate. Review beneficiary designations regularly to ensure they reflect your wishes and name contingent beneficiaries in case your primary choice predeceases you.

Q5: Is a living trust better than avoiding probate with beneficiary designations?

Answer: Living trusts offer advantages beyond probate avoidance: privacy (distributions aren’t public), incapacity planning (successor trustee manages assets if you’re incapacitated), and continuity (no probate delays). However, trusts require upfront cost and ongoing maintenance. For many people, a combination of beneficiary designations, joint ownership, and a pour-over will (which directs any remaining assets to the trust) provides cost-effective probate avoidance.

Q6: What is the North Carolina small estate threshold?

Answer: North Carolina allows small estate procedures for estates not exceeding $20,000 in total assets (for estates without real property) or $30,000 (for estates where the surviving spouse is the sole heir). Qualifying estates use a simplified affidavit process instead of formal probate court proceedings. If your estate exceeds these thresholds and includes assets titled individually without beneficiaries, formal probate is typically required.

Q7: Can property titled in one person’s name avoid probate?

Answer: Property titled solely in the deceased’s individual name typically requires probate unless it’s very small or qualifies for expedited small estate procedures. To avoid probate, consider beneficiary designations (for bank accounts, investments), transfer-on-death registrations (for real property, vehicles), joint ownership with survivorship rights, or a revocable living trust. Proper titling during life is essential for probate avoidance.

Conclusion

Whether probate is required depends on your specific circumstances: the estate’s size, how assets are titled, and whether you have beneficiary designations or a trust in place. While probate provides important protections and formality, the costs and delays often make probate avoidance preferable.

By understanding these rules and using proper estate planning strategies, beneficiary designations, joint ownership, living trusts, and transfer-on-death registrations, you can help your family avoid probate and reduce administrative burdens during an already difficult time.

North Carolina residents should note the state’s generous small estate thresholds ($20,000-$30,000) and consider whether their estates qualify. For larger estates with significant assets titled individually, a living trust or comprehensive beneficiary designation strategy provides effective probate avoidance.

Consult with an estate planning attorney in your state to develop a strategy tailored to your assets, goals, and family situation. Proper planning now ensures your estate transfers smoothly to your heirs later.

Metadata

Primary Keyword: When probate is needed Secondary Keywords: When probate is not required, small estate procedures, living trusts, beneficiary designations Word Count: 2,087 words Target Word Count: 1,800-2,200 words Estimated Reading Time: 8-10 minutes Content Type: Informational/Educational Last Updated: January 28, 2026

Ready to make this easier?

Afterpath guides you through every step of the probate process.

Join the Waitlist