Probate vs. Non-Probate Assets: What Goes Through Probate and What Doesn't

The Single Most Important Distinction You Need to Understand

When someone dies, their assets don’t automatically go to whoever they want. Some assets require court approval (probate). Others bypass the court entirely and go directly to named beneficiaries (non-probate).

Understanding the difference between probate and non-probate assets is the single most important thing you need to grasp as an executor.

Here’s why: an asset’s path through the estate depends entirely on whether it’s a probate asset or a non-probate asset. This distinction affects:

• Whether the court is involved
• How long distribution takes
• Whether creditors can claim the asset
• How the executor handles it
• What beneficiaries receive and when

Get this wrong and you can delay distributions, inadvertently let assets sit unclaimed, or distribute things incorrectly.

---

What Is a Probate Asset?

A probate asset is property that the deceased person owned in their name alone, with no named beneficiary, and with no other ownership structure that bypasses probate.

Examples of probate assets:

• Bank accounts in the deceased’s name only (no POD, no joint ownership)
• Investment accounts titled in the deceased’s name alone
• Real estate owned in the deceased’s name alone
• Vehicles titled in the deceased’s name alone
• Personal property (furniture, jewelry, art, collectibles)
• Retirement accounts with no named beneficiary
• Life insurance policies with the estate named as beneficiary

What makes something a probate asset: The deceased person owned it outright, in their name alone, with no arrangement to transfer it outside of probate.

What happens to probate assets:

1. They’re included in the probate estate
2. They’re listed on the inventory you file with the court
3. They’re subject to creditor claims (creditors can file claims and get paid from these assets)
4. They’re distributed according to the will or NC intestacy law
5. The distribution requires court approval
6. They typically can’t be distributed until probate is complete

---

What Is a Non-Probate Asset?

A non-probate asset is property with built-in instructions for who receives it after death, bypassing probate court entirely.

Examples of non-probate assets:

• Bank accounts with “payable on death” (POD) designation
• Retirement accounts (401k, IRA) with named beneficiaries
• Life insurance policies with named beneficiaries (not the estate)
• Brokerage accounts with transfer-on-death (TOD) provisions
• Real estate held as joint tenants with rights of survivorship
• Property held in a trust
• Vehicles with beneficiary designations (some states)

What makes something a non-probate asset: There’s a specific instruction for who receives it outside of probate. The owner designated a beneficiary during their lifetime, and that designation survives death.

What happens to non-probate assets:

1. They skip probate entirely
2. They’re not listed on the probate inventory
3. They’re NOT subject to creditor claims (creditors can’t touch them in most cases)
4. They go directly to the named beneficiary
5. The beneficiary can collect them without court approval
6. They can be transferred immediately (even before probate starts)

---

The Critical Difference: This Changes Everything

Let’s compare side-by-side:

Factor	Probate Asset	Non-Probate Asset
Court involved?	Yes	No
Time to distribute	8+ months (or longer)	Days or weeks
Creditor claims	Yes, creditors can claim	No, generally protected
Will determines distribution	Yes	No, beneficiary designation does
Executor approval needed	Yes	No, beneficiary just collects
Part of taxable estate	Yes	Yes (for tax purposes) but bypasses probate
Public record	Yes	No

Here’s what this means in practical terms:

Probate asset example: Your parent dies with $150,000 in a savings account titled “John Smith” (just their name, no beneficiary). This $150,000 sits in the account, untouched, while probate processes. It gets listed on inventory, it’s available to pay creditors, it takes 8-12 months to distribute to beneficiaries. Eventually, if there’s money left after paying debts, the beneficiaries get it.

Non-probate asset example: Your parent dies with $150,000 in a money market account with “payable on death” to “Mary Smith.” The day after death, Mary calls the bank, provides a death certificate, and within days the bank transfers the $150,000 directly to her account. The executor doesn’t handle it. The court doesn’t get involved. Creditors can’t touch it. Mary has her $150,000.

Same amount of money. Completely different outcome.

---

Key Types of Non-Probate Assets and How They Work

1. Bank Accounts with POD (Payable on Death) Designation

This is the simplest and most common non-probate asset.

How it works:

• The deceased opened an account and added a POD beneficiary
• They can still use the account and change the beneficiary while alive
• When they die, the bank verifies death and transfers to the POD beneficiary
• Takes 1-2 weeks typically

Example: Sarah sets up a savings account with “payable on death to Michael Smith.” When Sarah dies, Michael contacts the bank with the death certificate. The bank transfers all funds directly to Michael. Done.

What the executor needs to do: Nothing. The POD beneficiary handles it directly with the bank. The executor doesn’t touch this account.

2. Retirement Accounts (401k, IRA, etc.) with Named Beneficiaries

Retirement accounts typically have named beneficiaries who receive the funds directly.

How it works:

• The deceased named a beneficiary on the account when they opened it (or updated it later)
• When they die, the account custodian is notified
• The custodian pays the named beneficiary
• The beneficiary may need to open an inherited account to receive distributions

Tax consideration: The beneficiary may owe income taxes on distributions (varies depending on account type and beneficiary relationship).

What the executor needs to do: Usually nothing. The beneficiary contacts the account custodian directly and handles collection. However, if the estate is named as beneficiary (which is problematic), the executor must address it.

Red flag: If a retiree never named a beneficiary on a 401k or IRA, the account goes through probate. This is terrible, it exposes the account to creditor claims and delays distribution to beneficiaries. This is one of the most common mistakes in estate planning.

3. Life Insurance Policies with Named Beneficiaries

Life insurance is a major non-probate asset if the beneficiary is correctly named.

How it works:

• The deceased bought a life insurance policy and named a beneficiary
• When they die, the insurance company is notified
• The company pays the named beneficiary a death benefit (the policy amount)
• No probate required

What the executor needs to do: Locate the policy (check documents, financial records, or contact the insurance company) and notify the insurer. The beneficiary then collects the death benefit.

Red flag: If the deceased named the estate as beneficiary or left the beneficiary field blank, the insurance proceeds go through probate. This defeats the purpose of insurance and exposes money that was supposed to go directly to loved ones to creditor claims.

Another red flag: If the deceased had multiple life insurance policies, each with a different beneficiary, make sure those beneficiaries are still correct. People sometimes update their will and forget to update insurance beneficiaries (which take precedence over the will).

4. Transfer on Death (TOD) Brokerage Accounts

Some brokerage accounts allow a TOD designation, similar to POD for bank accounts.

How it works:

• The deceased designated a TOD beneficiary when opening the account
• When they die, the brokerage transfers the account to the beneficiary
• The beneficiary can liquidate or continue managing the account

What the executor needs to do: Nothing. The beneficiary handles it with the brokerage.

5. Real Estate Held as Joint Tenants with Rights of Survivorship

If real estate is owned by multiple people with “rights of survivorship,” the property automatically goes to the surviving owners when one owner dies.

How it works:

• Property is titled “John Smith and Mary Smith, as joint tenants with rights of survivorship”
• When John dies, Mary automatically becomes the sole owner
• No probate needed
• Mary just records a death certificate with the county to update title

What the executor needs to do: Notify the surviving owner about the change. Record the death certificate to formally update title. That’s it.

Important distinction: This is different from “tenants in common.” If property is held as tenants in common, the deceased’s share goes through probate. Be clear on the title structure.

6. Real Estate Held in a Trust

If real estate (or other assets) are held in a revocable living trust, they bypass probate entirely.

How it works:

• The deceased transferred property into a trust during their lifetime
• The trust names a beneficiary or successor trustee
• When the owner dies, the trustee (or successor trustee) distributes the property to beneficiaries per the trust terms
• No probate needed

What the executor needs to do: Work with the trustee to ensure proper distribution. If the deceased was the trustee, the successor trustee takes over.

Note: This is a sophisticated planning tool. Many people with trusts have a will anyway (pour-over will) that catches assets not transferred to the trust.

---

How to Identify Which Assets Are Probate vs. Non-Probate

As executor, you need to classify every asset. Here’s how:

Ask these questions for each asset:

1. Is there a named beneficiary?

   • Retirement accounts? Check for named beneficiary
   • Life insurance? Check the policy for beneficiary
   • Bank accounts? Check for POD designation
   • Brokerage accounts? Check for TOD designation

2. Is the property held in joint names with survivorship?

   • Real estate titled “John and Mary, joint tenants with rights of survivorship” = non-probate
   • Real estate titled “John and Mary, tenants in common” = probate (at least the deceased’s share)

3. Is the property held in a trust?

   • If yes, it’s non-probate (trust handles it)
   • If no, and no named beneficiary, it’s probate

The decision tree:

• Asset has named beneficiary → Non-probate (send beneficiary to institution)
• Asset held in trust → Non-probate (trust handles it)
• Asset held as joint tenants with survivorship → Non-probate (goes to survivor)
• Asset in deceased’s name only, no beneficiary, no survivorship → Probate (list on inventory)

---

Common Mistakes Executors Make with Asset Classification

Mistake #1: Assuming All Assets Go Through Probate

Many new executors think all assets must go through probate. Wrong. Non-probate assets should bypass you entirely. Don’t require beneficiaries to wait 8 months for probate to close just to collect something that was designated for them.

Correct approach: Identify non-probate assets immediately, notify the beneficiaries, and let them collect directly from the institution.

Mistake #2: Not Checking for Named Beneficiaries

A common scenario: Someone inherits a $200,000 IRA but doesn’t know the beneficiary field was never completed. The IRA goes through probate, gets exposed to creditors, and ends up going to the wrong people.

Correct approach: For every retirement account, life insurance policy, and financial account, confirm the named beneficiary. If there’s no beneficiary on something that should have one, address it as a probate asset and file it properly.

Mistake #3: Forgetting About POD Accounts

Older relatives sometimes set up POD accounts decades ago and forget about them. These accounts sit in the bank, the beneficiary doesn’t know about them, and they’re never collected.

Correct approach: Search for all bank accounts (check old statements, banks in the deceased’s town, etc.). For each one, ask the bank: “Is there a POD beneficiary on this account?”

Mistake #4: Not Updating Beneficiary Designations

Someone changes their will but forgets to update life insurance beneficiaries or retirement account beneficiaries. The will says “everything to my daughter” but the 401k still names “ex-spouse as beneficiary.”

Correct approach: For each financial account, confirm the beneficiary matches the person’s intent. If it doesn’t, the account bypasses probate and goes to whoever is named, regardless of the will.

Mistake #5: Treating Joint Property as Probate

If property is titled “John Smith and Mary Smith, joint tenants with rights of survivorship,” it’s non-probate. Mary doesn’t need probate to take ownership; she already owns it by survivorship.

Correct approach: Review all deeds and titles carefully. If it says “joint tenants with rights of survivorship,” it’s non-probate.

Mistake #6: Forgetting the Trust

Some people have revocable living trusts and forget about them because the trust is essentially invisible during their lifetime. The deceased was both grantor and trustee, so nothing seemed different.

Correct approach: Search for trust documents. Ask: “Did the deceased have a revocable living trust?” If yes, property in the trust is non-probate.

---

Why This Distinction Matters: Real Consequences

Let’s look at realistic scenarios to understand why this distinction is so important:

Scenario 1: Probate vs. Non-Probate Life Insurance

Sarah dies with a $500,000 life insurance policy. Her will says “divide everything equally among my three children.”

If the policy names her estate as beneficiary (probate asset):

• The $500,000 goes into probate
• It becomes subject to creditor claims (her credit card debt of $30,000 gets paid first)
• Children wait 8-12 months to receive anything
• Net proceeds after debts and taxes might be $420,000 divided three ways

If the policy names her three children as beneficiaries equally (non-probate):

• Each child receives $166,666 directly from the insurance company
• Takes 2-3 weeks
• No creditor claims against insurance proceeds
• No waiting for probate
• Full amount goes to them

The difference: Same policy, same death, completely different outcomes for the children. One requires probate; one doesn’t.

---

Scenario 2: Bank Accounts

Tom dies with:

• Checking account: $25,000 (titled in Tom’s name only) = Probate asset
• Savings account: $50,000 (payable on death to his daughter) = Non-probate asset

Tom’s son is executor. His daughter needs to pay rent immediately (she’s going through hardship). Can the executor release funds to her?

From checking account: The executor can’t immediately. It’s a probate asset. The executor must wait for probate to close, creditors to be paid, and court approval to distribute.

From savings account: The daughter contacts the bank directly, provides the death certificate and POD documentation, and within days has access to $50,000. No executor involvement. No waiting.

The distinction literally determines who gets money and when.

---

Scenario 3: Real Estate with Hidden Debt

Jane owns a house worth $400,000 titled “Jane Smith and John Smith, as joint tenants with rights of survivorship.” Jane also has $150,000 in credit card debt and medical bills.

When Jane dies, John automatically becomes the sole owner of the house (non-probate, via survivorship). The house does NOT go through probate. It’s not part of the probate estate. The creditors cannot reach the house because it passed outside of probate.

The creditors’ claims are against the probate estate (whatever assets are in probate). If the probate estate has $100,000 total, creditors are paid from that. The house is protected because it transferred to John automatically through survivorship, not through probate.

This distinction saves the house.

---

The Impact on Probate Timeline and Cost

Here’s a practical reality: The more non-probate assets, the simpler and faster the probate process.

Estate with mostly probate assets:

• Full probate required
• 8-12 months or longer
• Court involvement for every transaction
• Significant legal fees if hiring an attorney
• All assets tied up during probate
• Creditors can claim against all assets

Estate with mostly non-probate assets:

• Minimal probate required (just probate assets)
• Non-probate assets transferred immediately to beneficiaries
• Less court involvement overall
• Lower legal fees (less work required)
• Beneficiaries get their designated assets within weeks
• Creditors can only claim against probate assets

The more your deceased person planned ahead (through POD accounts, named beneficiaries, trusts, joint ownership), the less probate work you have to do.

---

Common Questions About Asset Classification

Q: If someone names their estate as beneficiary on a retirement account, does the account go through probate? A: Yes. This is a mistake because it exposes the retirement account to creditor claims and delays distribution. If this happened, notify the account custodian and work with probate to collect and distribute the funds.

Q: If two people own property as “joint tenants with rights of survivorship” and both die in the same accident, what happens? A: If you can’t determine who died first, NC law treats it as if they died simultaneously. The property goes through both estates’ probate. This is why joint ownership works better when there’s a clear survivor.

Q: Can I change a POD or TOD beneficiary after someone dies? A: No. The beneficiary designation was set during the deceased’s lifetime and controls the distribution. You can’t change it. The named beneficiary receives the asset.

Q: If someone had a will that contradicts a beneficiary designation, which controls? A: The beneficiary designation controls. The will doesn’t override a named beneficiary on a specific account. This is why people sometimes make expensive mistakes, their will says one thing, but a 401k beneficiary field from decades ago says another.

Q: Are non-probate assets taxable? A: Yes, for federal estate tax purposes (if the estate is large enough). But they don’t go through probate court. They bypass probate but are still part of the taxable estate if the total exceeds the exemption threshold. This is why proper tax planning is important for large estates.

---

Practical Steps to Identify All Assets

When you’re first appointed as executor, do this:

1. Search for all documents:

   • Life insurance policies
   • Retirement account statements
   • Bank statements (last year of statements)
   • Brokerage statements
   • Deed to any real estate
   • Mortgage documents (if any)
   • Trust documents (if any)

2. For each financial account, ask:

   • Is there a named beneficiary? (Call the institution if unsure)
   • Is there a POD/TOD designation? (Check the account documents)
   • If no beneficiary, ask the institution what happens

3. For each property:

   • Check the deed/title
   • Does it say “joint tenants with rights of survivorship”?
   • Does it say “as tenants in common”?
   • Is it held in a trust?

4. Create a simple spreadsheet:

   • Asset name | Asset value | Probate or Non-probate? | Beneficiary (if any)

This simple exercise prevents missed assets and ensures correct handling.

---

FAQ: Probate vs. Non-Probate Assets

Q: How do I know if an asset is probate or non-probate? A: Check for a named beneficiary, POD/TOD designation, or trust ownership. If none exist and the deceased owned it in their name alone, it’s probate.

Q: Can creditors claim against non-probate assets? A: Generally no. This is one of the main advantages of non-probate assets, they’re protected from creditors. (Exception: some creditors, like the IRS, have special rights.)

Q: If someone dies without a will, do non-probate assets still go to the named beneficiaries? A: Yes. Non-probate designations override the absence of a will. If there’s a named beneficiary, they get the asset even without a will.

Q: What if someone named beneficiaries that I think are wrong? A: If the beneficiary designation is legal and clearly named, that beneficiary gets the asset. The only exception is if you can prove the designation was made through fraud or undue influence, which requires legal action. Generally, you can’t override a named beneficiary.

Q: Should I try to move non-probate assets into probate? A: No. Let non-probate assets flow to their named beneficiaries. This is what the deceased intended and is far simpler for everyone.

Q: What’s the best way to set up accounts to avoid probate? A: Use POD/TOD designations, name beneficiaries on retirement and insurance accounts, hold property in joint names with survivorship, or use a trust. This is a planning question for the deceased’s lawyer, not something you as executor address.

---

The Bottom Line

Every asset falls into one of two categories: probate or non-probate. Understanding which is which determines:

• Whether it goes through court
• How fast beneficiaries receive it
• Whether creditors can claim it
• What the executor must do

Non-probate assets, properly set up, skip probate entirely and go directly to beneficiaries. Probate assets require court involvement and take longer.

Most people don’t plan for this distinction, which is why many estates are more complicated than they need to be. But as executor, understanding the difference helps you navigate what you’ve inherited, literally.

Get this right, and probate becomes significantly simpler.