Probate vs Administration in NC: Understanding the Difference

Two Paths Through the Same Court System

When someone dies in North Carolina, one of two things is true: they either left a valid will, or they didn’t. That single fact determines which legal process their estate goes through, and the difference matters more than most families realize.

North Carolina law distinguishes clearly between probate (handling an estate where the deceased left a valid will, known as dying “testate”) and administration (handling an estate where there is no valid will, known as dying “intestate”). Both processes move through the same Clerk of Superior Court. Both result in debts being paid and assets being distributed. But the authority structures, the court forms, the titles given to the person in charge, and the rules that govern decisions are meaningfully different.

If you’re stepping into the role of managing a deceased family member’s estate, knowing which process applies to you determines what you can and cannot do, what documents you’ll file, and how much discretion you actually have.

Afterpath’s Pathfinder identifies your situation immediately. Tell Pathfinder whether there’s a will, and the entire task list, forms checklist, and county-specific filing guide reconfigure for your exact process. You won’t be following generic probate guidance; you’ll be following the right guidance for your situation.

Dying Testate: Probate With a Will

When someone dies leaving a valid will in North Carolina, we say they died “testate.” Their estate goes through the probate process, governed primarily by North Carolina General Statutes Chapter 28A.

What Makes a Will Valid in NC

Before a will can be probated, the court must be satisfied it meets NC’s legal requirements:

• Written document: The will must be in writing (NC does recognize handwritten, or “holographic,” wills under strict conditions)
• Signed by the testator: The person making the will must have signed it or directed someone to sign it in their presence
• Witnessed: A standard typed will requires two witnesses who also signed in the testator’s presence
• Mental capacity: The testator must have been of sound mind at the time of signing

If the will meets these requirements, the Clerk of Superior Court will admit it to probate.

The Executor: Authority Flows from the Will

In a testate estate, the will typically names someone to manage the estate. That person is called the executor (sometimes called a “personal representative” in modern legal terminology). The executor’s authority is rooted in two sources: the will itself, and the court’s formal appointment.

The will might say something like: “I appoint my daughter, Margaret Anne Davis, as executor of this will.” But Margaret doesn’t actually have legal authority to manage the estate until the court formally recognizes her role.

That formal recognition comes through Letters Testamentary, the official court document that gives the executor power to access accounts, manage assets, pay debts, and distribute property. Without Letters Testamentary, banks won’t release funds, title companies won’t transfer property, and brokers won’t allow account access. See our guide to Letters Testamentary in North Carolina for the full step-by-step process.

What the Executor Can and Cannot Do

The executor’s powers are significant, but they’re also constrained. The executor must:

• Follow the specific instructions in the will
• Act in the best interest of the estate and all beneficiaries
• Follow NC probate law regardless of what the will says (the law sets a floor on executor obligations)
• File required court forms and meet all deadlines

The executor cannot:

• Deviate from the will’s clear terms without court approval
• Favor one beneficiary over others in violation of the will
• Self-deal (benefit personally at the estate’s expense without proper disclosure)
• Ignore creditors or skip the required notice period

The will can expand or restrict the executor’s powers in various ways. For example, many wills include a “power of sale” clause that lets the executor sell real property without court approval, while wills without such clauses require the executor to get court permission before selling real estate.

Dying Intestate: Administration Without a Will

When someone dies without a valid will in North Carolina, they died “intestate.” Instead of probate, the estate goes through administration, also governed by NC General Statutes Chapter 28A but following a fundamentally different process.

No one inherits by anyone’s specific wishes. Instead, NC’s intestate succession statutes (NCGS §§ 29-14 through 29-30) dictate exactly who inherits and in what shares. The law substitutes for the will the deceased never wrote. For a complete breakdown of those inheritance rules, see our guide to NC intestate succession.

The Administrator: Appointed by the Court

In an intestate estate, there is no will naming anyone to manage things. The court appoints someone for the job. That person is called the administrator rather than an executor.

NC law creates a priority list for who the court will appoint as administrator:

1. The surviving spouse (if any)
2. The next of kin in the order they would inherit
3. Any creditor of the estate (if no family steps forward)
4. Any other person the court finds suitable

The administrator’s authority comes entirely from the court, not from a will. That authority is documented in Letters of Administration, the intestate equivalent of Letters Testamentary.

Letters of Administration vs. Letters Testamentary

Both documents grant the person managing the estate legal authority to act. Both are issued by the Clerk of Superior Court. But their origins and implications differ:

Feature	Letters Testamentary	Letters of Administration
Who receives them	Named executor (testate estate)	Court-appointed administrator (intestate estate)
What triggers them	Probated will	Petition to administer intestate estate
Authority basis	Will + court recognition	Court appointment alone
Distribution rules	Will’s terms	NC intestacy statutes
Discretion level	Generally more (will may expand powers)	More constrained (law controls distributions)

How the Administrator’s Discretion Differs

This is a critical distinction. An executor derives authority from the will, which may grant broad powers to manage and sell assets at the executor’s discretion. An administrator derives authority only from the court and NC law.

Without a will, the administrator typically has less built-in discretion. They cannot decide that one heir should receive more than another. They cannot choose to sell the house based on their personal judgment alone. NC’s intestacy statutes control who gets what, and the administrator must follow those rules.

In practice, this means intestate administration often involves more court oversight and fewer judgment calls by the person in charge. If the administrator wants to take an action not clearly authorized by statute, they may need to petition the court for guidance or approval.

The Probate Process: Step by Step for Testate Estates

Here’s how probate proceeds when there is a will in North Carolina:

Step 1: File the will and petition for probate The executor files the original will and the AOC-E-214 petition with the Clerk of Superior Court in the county where the deceased lived.

Step 2: Receive Letters Testamentary The clerk reviews the will, verifies it appears valid, and issues Letters Testamentary to the named executor. This typically takes 2-4 weeks.

Step 3: Publish notice to creditors The executor must notify creditors, either through direct notice or publication in a local newspaper, giving them 90 days to file claims.

Step 4: File inventory within 90 days The executor must file a complete inventory of all estate assets with the court within 90 days of the date Letters were issued.

Step 5: Pay debts and taxes Valid creditor claims are paid from estate assets in a specific priority order set by NC law.

Step 6: Distribute assets to beneficiaries After debts are paid, remaining assets are distributed according to the will’s instructions.

Step 7: File the final accounting The executor files a final accounting with the court showing all income, expenses, and distributions. Once approved, the estate closes.

The Administration Process: Step by Step for Intestate Estates

Administration follows a parallel but distinct track:

Step 1: Petition for letters of administration A qualified family member (usually the surviving spouse or next of kin) petitions the court for appointment as administrator, filing the AOC-E-202 form.

Step 2: Receive Letters of Administration After reviewing the petition and confirming there’s no will, the clerk appoints the administrator and issues Letters of Administration.

Step 3: Publish notice to creditors Same 90-day creditor notice requirement as testate estates.

Step 4: File inventory within 90 days Same 90-day inventory requirement.

Step 5: Determine heirs under NC intestacy law This step is unique to intestate estates. The administrator must identify all legal heirs according to NC’s intestacy rules and their exact shares.

Step 6: Pay debts Same priority order for paying creditors.

Step 7: Distribute to heirs per NC intestacy statutes Assets are distributed according to NC law, not the deceased’s wishes. The administrator has no discretion to change the distribution.

Step 8: File final accounting Same closing process as testate estates.

Afterpath’s task management system generates the correct checklist for your situation. Whether you’re an executor in a testate estate or an administrator in an intestate one, every task, deadline, and form is laid out specifically for your county and your role. You won’t be guessing what comes next.

Key Practical Differences: What Families Need to Know

Beyond the terminology and legal structure, several practical differences affect real families:

Distribution: Clarity vs. Uncertainty

In a testate estate, everyone can read the will and understand what they’ll receive. The executor follows those instructions. Disputes still happen, but there’s a document to reference.

In an intestate estate, the distribution rules come from a statute most families have never read. People sometimes receive shares they didn’t expect, and people sometimes receive nothing when they thought they’d inherit something. A deceased person’s unmarried partner, for example, has no intestacy rights in NC regardless of how long they were together.

Timeline Differences

Both processes take roughly the same time from start to finish (typically 6-18 months in NC), but testate estates can sometimes move faster because the will provides clear direction. Intestate estates sometimes slow down when there are disputes about who qualifies as an heir, when heirs cannot be located, or when the family structure is complex (children from multiple relationships, disputes about paternity, etc.).

Executor Compensation

Both executors and administrators are entitled to reasonable compensation under NC law, typically up to 5% of receipts and disbursements. But an executor named in the will may have their compensation specifically set by the will (either specifying an amount or waiving it). An administrator’s compensation is governed entirely by statute.

Bond Requirements

NC generally requires administrators to post a bond (essentially an insurance policy protecting the estate from the administrator’s mistakes or misconduct). Executors named in a will may have the bond requirement waived if the will specifically says so. This is a common will provision that saves time and expense. Without a waiver, the bonding requirement applies. See our guide on NC probate bond requirements for details.

Special Situation: What if a Will Is Found After Administration Begins?

Occasionally, administration begins because no will was found, and then a will surfaces later. This creates a complicated situation.

Under NC law, a will must be filed with the court within a reasonable time. If a will is found after letters of administration have already been issued, the process can shift from administration to probate, but unwinding what’s already been done is legally complex.

If you’re searching for a will and haven’t found one, continue searching thoroughly before petitioning for administration. Check the deceased’s home, safe deposit boxes, attorney’s office, and the NC Clerk’s records. Our guide on how to find out if someone left a will in NC covers the search process in detail.

How Afterpath Supports Both Processes

Whether you’re managing a testate probate or an intestate administration, Afterpath provides the same core tools configured for your specific situation.

Pathfinder answers your questions about the process, explains what the will does and doesn’t say, clarifies NC intestacy rules for your specific family structure, and tells you what to expect at each stage.

Task management generates a complete, deadline-tracked checklist from day one. For executors, tasks reference the will’s instructions. For administrators, tasks are anchored to NC intestacy statutes.

NC compliance engine ensures every form you file matches your county’s requirements. The difference between an AOC-E-214 (testate) and an AOC-E-202 (intestate) matters, and Afterpath generates the right one for you.

Document vault stores the will (if any), death certificate, Letters Testamentary or Letters of Administration, inventory, creditor notices, and final accounting in one organized, secure location.

Professional marketplace connects you to vetted NC estate attorneys if the situation becomes complicated, a contested will, a disputed heir, an unusually complex asset structure.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I choose whether to go through probate or administration?

A: No. The process is determined by whether the deceased left a valid will. If there’s a valid will, probate applies. If there’s no valid will (or the will is found invalid), administration applies. You don’t elect between the two.

Q: What if the deceased had a will but also had a lot of assets without beneficiaries named?

A: The will still controls. The estate goes through probate, and the executor follows the will’s instructions for distributing assets. Assets without separate beneficiary designations become part of the probate estate and are distributed per the will.

Q: Can an administrator sell property without court approval?

A: Generally, an administrator has less flexibility to sell property than an executor with a power of sale clause in the will. Without court approval or clear statutory authority, property sales by administrators require more careful navigation of NC law. This is one reason intestate estates sometimes need attorney involvement.

Q: Is one process faster than the other?

A: Not significantly. Both require the 90-day creditor notice period, the 90-day inventory filing, and a final accounting before the estate closes. Testate estates might move slightly faster because the will provides clear guidance, but a simple intestate estate can close just as quickly as a simple testate one.

Q: How does Afterpath know which process I’m in?

A: When you set up your case in Afterpath, you indicate whether the deceased left a will. Pathfinder and the task management system use that information to configure everything for your specific process, testate or intestate, from that point forward.

Moving Forward: Which Process Applies to You?

Start by answering one question: did the deceased leave a valid will?

If yes, you’re in probate. Find the will, file it with the Clerk of Superior Court in the right county, and petition for Letters Testamentary.

If no, you’re in administration. Confirm there is truly no will (search thoroughly), then petition the court for Letters of Administration.

Both paths are manageable. Both can be navigated without an attorney for straightforward estates. And both are covered, step by step, inside Afterpath.

Ready to get started on the right path?

Afterpath identifies your process, generates your task list, and walks you through every step from opening the estate to closing it. Your first assessment is free.

Start Your Estate Assessment →